Convenience stores in New Middletown, Ohio The most complete information about Convenience stores in New Middletown, Ohio: Addresses, phone numbers, reviews and other information. All stores Clothing Convenience Hardware Home goods All convenience stores in New Middletown BP Convenience Open now Open 24 Hours 10020 Youngstown - Pittsburgh Road, New Middletown, OH 44442 Get Directions Contacts Write a review Tic Toc Food Marts Convenience Closed now 10020 Youngstown - Pittsburgh Road, New Middletown, OH 44442 Get Directions Contacts Write a review Trip a Lot Convenience 5515 New Castle Road, New Middletown, OH 44442 Get Directions Contacts Write a review ✗ Facebook Google Plus Twitter